Math tutor and student reviewing a health claims textbook together
| |

Why Analytical Skills Learned in Math Tutoring Improve Student Health Education Awareness

When asked, many teens will say things like “I saw it online” or “A lot of people say so” when explaining how they evaluate health claims. Teachers and parents are right to be concerned with the constant barrage of health-related information such as fitness and diet trends, sleep, mental and other forms of wellness, and purported cures. Understanding health claims is more a matter of critical thinking than memorized knowledge. Parents may worry that their child will not be able to discern fact from fiction on their own. Quite often, parents, teachers and others worry in vain. Children develop critical thinking skills on their own, and a good math tutor nurtures that.

Families interested in math tutoring often focus on good grades and test scores. Good grades are good, but the skills needed to translate a math equation to the real world are invaluable and far-reaching. The skills needed to assess the veracity of a health claim are the same ones needed to read and interpret a nutrition label and make health and wellness choices. This article discusses these transference skills, their role in health education, and how to use them.

Analytical Thinking Is a Skill for Life

Analytical thinking is breaking a problem into smaller parts and using evidence and logic to come to a conclusion that justifies the answer. Math trains analytical thinking because each problem requires a justification for the answer; it can’t just be given as a declarative statement. Students have to show their work to justify their answer.

A quality online tutor uses a similar strategy. Rather than just handing over the answer, tutors help students understand the problem and arrive at the answer on their own by asking guiding questions. What do we know? What are we looking to find? What comes first? Does this make sense? After some time, students naturally internalize this process and assume this role for themselves.

Now picture that same student reading an article about a new supplement. What does the article say? Is there evidence to support the claims? How many people were in the study? Does the study come to the same conclusion? A student who is taught to evaluate the sense and validity of an answer is already partway to being a responsible consumer of health and fitness information.

This is why it’s important to teach reasoning skills alongside health education. Knowledge about health and nutrition can become outdated, but the skill to evaluate reasoning will always be useful.

Health Messages Include Lots of Numbers

Numbers appear in virtually all messages related to health. A message may say that the use of a drug reduces the risk of a disease by 50%. A food may contain 20% of the daily value of sodium. Teens should get 8 to 10 hours of sleep. It has been reported that a particular habit “doubles” the risk of a disease. The reading public may not have the number sense to evaluate these messages. A risk that was 1 in 10,000 and is now 2 in 10,000 is still small in absolute terms, yet many readers either overreact to the doubling or ignore messages unless the numbers are unusually large or small.

Health messages use the following math concepts:

  • Percentages and ratios. Students who have a good understanding of percentages would not be as alarmed by the relative increase from 1 in 10,000 to 2 in 10,000. Good number sense prompts a reader to look for the baseline.
  • Estimation. Being able to estimate and compare quantities, and to understand the relationship between quantities, helps one determine hydration, caloric balance, and serving size without using a fitness app.
  • Probability. The overlap between health education and probability helps students avoid jumping to conclusions based on anecdotal evidence like “I ate this and it made me feel better, so it must work.”

Health education becomes more like a game or puzzle than a list of rules when practice is frequent. Students are able to engage mentally with the material rather than simply memorizing rules, which greatly enhances retention.

Routine Practice Improves Health Education

Making decisions about one’s health is seldom easy and requires a high degree of judgment. Health education combined with probability strengthens skills students already possess and helps them decide on personal actions. For example, how should a student decide on the best way to juggle activities to reduce stress and improve concentration before exams? Should they join a sport, and how should they manage the time to do homework? What is an acceptable way to eat healthier on a shoestring budget? These situations are very similar to the ones students learn to solve in math using case analysis and steps to a solution.

As you consider ways of teaching your students to make health decisions, ask the following: “What is my health goal?” and “What information do I need to gather to help me decide on strategies to promote better health?” Once the information is gathered, ask students to consider: “What strategies do I need to try?” and “How should I try it to see if it makes a difference?” What difference has it made? Consider this when thinking about next steps.

Students who have been coached to think this way look at their wellbeing with curiosity, not panic. They think of problems as challenges to be worked out rather than as things that happen to them. This sense of control is one of the most important things a young person can have.

There is also an emotional side. Difficult math helps a student build resilience. A student who has worked through a math problem and finally solved it learns that frustration is only temporary and that with effort, he or she can accomplish a goal. This sense of resilience helps students cope with stress and setbacks in their lives.

There are limits, however, and students need to recognize when a problem is too big for them to take on themselves. A young person suffering with anxiety or depression, for example, could be led to ask for the help of a professional rather than trying to sort it out alone. That person could be the school counselor or family doctor, or a virtual psychiatrist. Knowing when and how to ask for professional help is important.

Critical Evaluation Protects Students From Health Misinformation

Now more than ever, with the ubiquitous presence of misinformation online, it is critical to educate students on how to integrate health and math skills. Social media algorithms reward posts for being emotional and shareable, which means that sometimes the most sensible, factually correct information gets lost, including information about a range of conditions from mental illnesses to cancers.

Students who have a foundation in analytical math skills can almost instinctively ask questions that strengthen their critical evaluation of health information, including the following:

  • What is the source? Are the claims posted by an individual, are they based on a study, or are they published by a reputable health organization?
  • What is the sample size? Is the claim generalizable to a larger population?
  • What is the comparison group? Are there other factors that could have caused the outcome?
  • Is it too good to be true? If a claim seems unbelievable, is the evidence equally unbelievable?
  • Does the math make sense? Are statistics and claims supported by data?

Teachers can enhance this critical evaluation skill by incorporating health information into the curriculum. Students can examine case studies of advertisements and other health-related materials. Students often find these lessons interesting, as they are taught to be critical of health-related advertisements and other media, and to be aware of the facts related to their everyday lives.

Parents can try this at home too. When a news article about a health study comes out, have your child explain the numbers to you. When a product claims dramatic effects, ask them to find the evidence. We are not trying to make kids cynical. We are trying to make them interested, and able to be critical of things.

How Parents and Educators Can Strengthen the Connection

This type of program is not difficult to implement. With a few habits, it can be accomplished:

  • Seek tutoring that focuses on reasoning. There are a variety of flexible online tutoring options. Ask potential tutors if they focus on having students justify their thinking instead of just providing an answer. Since tutoring can be customized to the student, it can include topics like basic statistical analysis, data interpretation, and math that pertains to public health and health issues.
  • Use real-world examples. When incorporating real-life situations like food logging, activity tracking, or sleep logging, tutors can help students understand how math and statistics pertain to the real world.
  • Ask for reasoning and justification, not just a yes or no answer. When a student explains how they concluded that a health claim is unsubstantiated, that reasoning can be used to evaluate public health claims in the future.
  • Demonstrate this yourself. Show your child that you read labels, check sources, and analyze things for yourself to determine if they are justified.

The motivational impact of wellbeing education is significantly improved when it is framed in a positive light and centered on the skills students can develop and control.

FAQs

Can math tutoring really improve health education?

Yes. Evaluating a health claim uses the same moves as checking a math answer: break the claim into parts, look at the evidence, test whether the numbers make sense, and justify the conclusion. A tutor who teaches students to show their work is building the exact habit a careful reader of health information needs.

Which math skills matter most for understanding health claims?

Percentages and ratios come first, because most health statistics are expressed as relative changes against a baseline. Estimation helps with everyday choices like serving sizes and hydration, and a basic feel for probability helps students see why one person’s story is not proof that something works.

How can I practice these skills with my child at home?

When a health study makes the news, ask your child to explain the numbers to you. When a product promises dramatic results, ask them to find the evidence behind the claim. The goal is not to make kids cynical; it is to make them curious and capable critics of the information they see every day.

When should a student ask a professional for help?

Analytical skills have limits, and students should recognize when a problem is too big to handle alone. A young person dealing with anxiety or depression, for example, benefits from talking to a school counselor, a family doctor, or another qualified professional. Knowing when to ask for help is itself a smart decision.

The Bottom Line

The relationship between mathematical thinking and health consciousness is stronger than most people realize. Breaking down a problem, asking “How do I know if I am getting it right?”, and explaining one’s reasoning can deepen students’ understanding of health-related information and their confidence in dealing with health-related choices. Strong health education brings knowledge to students; strong thinking skills enable them to use that knowledge wisely. And if you are looking for a tutor who teaches your student to justify their thinking rather than just find answers, the Matheaze team is always glad to talk about academic support in Math, Science, English Language Arts.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Prove your humanity: 1   +   3   =